Songleader Marsha Attie leading campers in movement at the stage, 2008

Songleader Marsha Attie leading campers in movement at the stage, 2008

Songleader Marsha Attie leading campers in movement at the stage, 2008

Songleader Marsha Attie leading campers in movement at the stage, 2008

Chapter Seven

Tawonga in the 2000s

L’dor V’dor

(From Generation to Generation)

Staff member Jamie Rotter, right, with camper

Staff member Jamie Rotter, right, with camper

By the end of the 1990s, Tawonga had become an independent and growing organization, with established traditions, expanded programs, and an experienced leadership team.

The 2000s brought new initiatives and changes in the executive director role, but those changes unfolded gradually. L’dor v’dor — “from generation to generation” — took shape through overlapping generations of leadership: longtime directors, senior staff who had already carried responsibility for years, and former campers stepping into new roles.

Across these generations, Tawonga’s leaders shared a commitment to preserve the traditions that defined camp while remaining open to change.

Tawonga is in a constant state of wanting to improve ourselves in whatever way we can. As we see the necessity to change, we will. But we have such rich traditions, and we still want those to be part of our culture.”
- Tawonga’s director, Mimi Gordon, quoted in the Northern California Jewish Bulletin, 2008

Eytan Elterman, left, and Tamir Elterman in the kitchen

Eytan Elterman, left, and Tamir Elterman in the kitchen

Songleaders Isaac Zones (left) and Gal Friedman (right), 2008

Songleaders Isaac Zones (left) and Gal Friedman (right), 2008

Songleaders Isaac Zones (left) and Gal Friedman (right), 2008

Songleaders Isaac Zones (left) and Gal Friedman (right), 2008

An Outdoor Sanctuary

In 2002, Camp Tawonga opened a new outdoor sanctuary: Makom Shalom, Hebrew for “place of peace.” Built with support from the Leslie family, the sanctuary gave camp a dedicated space for Saturday morning Torah services, which had previously been held near the main stage by the Dining Hall.

The selected site made use of a natural amphitheater tucked among trees, granite boulders, and sloping ground above the river valley. Simple wooden benches formed the main seating area, while the surrounding boulders became part of the sanctuary itself.

Tawongans heading to Makom Shalom for Torah services on a Saturday morning

Tawongans heading to Makom Shalom for Torah services on a Saturday morning

Makom Shalom quickly became one of Tawonga’s most important sacred spaces, giving permanent form to an idea Deborah Newbrun had long taught at camp: that Jewish prayer and ritual could be deepened by being outdoors, among the trees, granite, and river canyon that shaped daily life at Tawonga.

Deborah Newbrun and Anna Gerrard wrote the Tawonga Shabbat Morning Prayer Book, which still provides the basic structure for Tawonga’s Torah service.

Deborah Newbrun and Anna Gerrard wrote the Tawonga Shabbat Morning Prayer Book, which still provides the basic structure for Tawonga’s Torah service.

Working Toward Peace

In 2002, Camp Tawonga launched the Oseh Shalom ~ Sanea al-Salam Peacemakers Weekend, bringing together Israeli Jews, Palestinian Arabs, and Bay Area participants for several days of dialogue, shared meals, and camp life.

Led by Ken Kramarz and Ann Gonski in partnership with peace activists Len and Libby Traubman, the program reflected a belief that understanding could begin with listening and living together. The annual weekend continued through 2007.

Peace activists Libby and Len Traubman

Peace activists Libby and Len Traubman

Len Traubman, speaking at a Peacemakers Weekend welcome gathering

Len Traubman, speaking at a Peacemakers Weekend welcome gathering

The weekends included discussion groups, music, shared rituals, and time outdoors. At the close of the gatherings, participants stood together in the Tuolumne River, washing one another’s hands in the flowing water.

A 2005 Jewish Bulletin article described the gathering as “magical,” quoting one Israeli participant who reflected that, only a short time earlier, the people standing together in the river might instead have met on opposite sides of the conflict.

Aaron Mandel speaking at a Peacemakers Weekend gathering, 2007

Aaron Mandel speaking at a Peacemakers Weekend gathering, 2007

Hebrew version of Camp Tawonga’s logo, originally made for Peacemakers Weekend

Hebrew version of Camp Tawonga’s logo, originally made for Peacemakers Weekend

Arabic version of Camp Tawonga’s logo, originally made for Peacemakers Weekend

Arabic version of Camp Tawonga’s logo, originally made for Peacemakers Weekend

Ann Gonski, right, with a participant at an Oseh Shalom ~ Sanea al-Salam Peacemakers Weekend. The banner reads “As-salamu alaykum” — “peace be upon you” in Arabic.

Ann Gonski, right, with a participant at an Oseh Shalom ~ Sanea al-Salam Peacemakers Weekend. The banner reads “As-salamu alaykum” — “peace be upon you” in Arabic.

Nina Kaufman, second from left, in El Salvador, 2003. Margaux Permutt is second from the right.

Nina Kaufman, second from left, in El Salvador, 2003. Margaux Permutt is second from the right.

Tawongans in Israel, led by Aaron Mandel (in the back on the right)

Tawongans in Israel, led by Aaron Mandel (in the back on the right)

Tawongans volunteering in Costa Rica, 2009

Tawongans volunteering in Costa Rica, 2009

Tawongans lighting Shabbat candles in Costa Rica, 2009

Tawongans lighting Shabbat candles in Costa Rica, 2009

Learning Across Borders

In 2003, Camp Tawonga hired Nina Kaufman to direct a new Teen Service Learning (TSL) program, expanding teen programming beyond camp itself. That summer, Tawonga teens traveled to El Salvador on a service-learning trip coordinated with American Jewish World Service. Campers worked and learned alongside locals.

Dining Hall plaque commemorating the 2003 trip to El Salvador

Dining Hall plaque commemorating the 2003 trip to El Salvador

Nina Kaufman, second from left, in El Salvador, 2003. Margaux Permutt is second from the right.

Nina Kaufman, second from left, in El Salvador, 2003. Margaux Permutt is second from the right.

The program continued over the next several years, with service trips to El Salvador (2003, 2004), Alaska (2004), and Costa Rica (2006, 2009, 2010 and 2014). The first Costa Rica trip came after Tawonga had planned a Teen Service Learning trip to Israel but shifted course because of security concerns.

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, February 3, 2006. (Note, this article describes an upcoming summer trip that was later postponed until 2007.)

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, February 3, 2006. (Note, this article describes an upcoming summer trip that was later postponed until 2007.)

In 2007, Tawonga was able to bring a group of teens and staff to Israel for service learning. Aaron Mandel (Tawonga’s current camp director) became the director of TSL in 2007 and supervised the trips to Israel.

Tawonga’s TSL program took a group of teens to Israel again in 2008 and in the summers of 2011, 2012, and 2013.

Dining Hall plaque commemorating the 2007 TSL trip to Israel

Dining Hall plaque commemorating the 2007 TSL trip to Israel

Tawongans in Israel, led by Aaron Mandel (in the back on the right)

Tawongans in Israel, led by Aaron Mandel (in the back on the right)

Natasha Litt’s homage to the famous New Yorker magazine cover, showing a Tawongan view of the world. Note the inclusion of Teen Service Learning destinations El Salvador, Israel, and Alaska in the distance.

Natasha Litt’s homage to the famous New Yorker magazine cover, showing a Tawongan view of the world. Note the inclusion of Teen Service Learning destinations El Salvador, Israel, and Alaska in the distance.

Tawongans volunteering in Costa Rica, 2009

Tawongans volunteering in Costa Rica, 2009

International staff (including Israeli shlichim on Shabbat, 2000s

International staff (including Israeli shlichim on Shabbat, 2000s

Israeli staff members, from left: Rei Dishon, Ronit Levin, and Lior Levi (second from right), 2000s

Israeli staff members, from left: Rei Dishon, Ronit Levin, and Lior Levi (second from right), 2000s

Noar l'Noar campers creating a "friendship knot," 2008

Noar l'Noar campers creating a "friendship knot," 2008

Campers and staff on Israel Day, 2000s

Campers and staff on Israel Day, 2000s

A Living Bridge

Beginning in the late 1990s and continuing through the early 2000s, Tawonga expanded its shlichim — or “emissaries” — program, bringing more Israeli counselors and staff into daily camp life. With support from the Richard and Rhoda Goldman Fund, the number of Israeli staff grew from two to five and then to 10 by 2003.

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, Jan 24, 2003

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, Jan 24, 2003

International staff (including Israeli shlichim on Shabbat, 2000s

International staff (including Israeli shlichim on Shabbat, 2000s

The shlichim served as counselors, song leaders, wilderness leaders, and other members of the summer staff. The goal was not simply to teach campers about Israel, but to create what Tawonga considered to be a “living bridge” between Jews in America and Jews in Israel — through music, Hebrew, wilderness trips, bunk life, and the ordinary relationships formed over the course of a summer.

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, May 23, 2003

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, May 23, 2003

Israeli staff members, from left: Rei Dishon, Ronit Levin, and Lior Levi (second from right), 2000s

Israeli staff members, from left: Rei Dishon, Ronit Levin, and Lior Levi (second from right), 2000s

Noar l’Noar

As travel to Israel declined during the Second Intifada, Noar l’Noar — “youth to youth” — brought Israeli campers to American Jewish camps. Ann Gonski championed bringing the program to Tawonga in 2003, with support from the Lisa and Douglas Goldman Fund.

For 14 years, Noar l’Noar invited Israeli teens to join cabin groups with American peers. Together, they backpacked, celebrated Shabbat, shared meals, and joined in the ordinary rhythms of camp. These experiences created direct relationships between American and Israeli teenagers — letting friendship and shared experience do much of the teaching.

“It’s easier here to be Jewish. Here, Judaism is a religion for the soul.”
- Asaf Tzur, Israeli camper, 2003

Noar l'Noar campers creating a "friendship knot," 2008

Noar l'Noar campers creating a "friendship knot," 2008

The first delegations came largely from northern Israel. Over time, Tawonga and its Israeli partners broadened the program to include more of Israel’s varied communities. Ethiopian Israeli teens joined in 2005; in 2007, a delegation of 24 included four Ethiopian Israeli and four Arab Israeli teens; and later groups included Druze campers. The exchanges gave American campers a fuller view of Israeli society while giving the visiting teens a different experience of Jewish practice and community.

An Ethiopian Israeli staff member in the Dining Hall, 2007

An Ethiopian Israeli staff member in the Dining Hall, 2007

Some Noar l’Noar participants later returned as CITs or shlichim, carrying relationships formed as campers into the staff community. Across many summers, Israeli and American young people met on trails, in cabins, around campfires, and in conversation.

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, August 26, 2005

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, August 26, 2005

Campers and staff on Israel Day, 2000s

Campers and staff on Israel Day, 2000s

Leadership Across Generations

By the early 2000s, Tawonga’s leadership was expanding across generations. Ken Kramarz, Deborah Newbrun, and Ann Gonski continued to guide camp. At the same time, Mimi Gordon had emerged as one of the leaders helping shape daily operations and staff culture.

Many other year-round and seasonal leaders had first worked at Tawonga as counselors, specialists, unit heads, kitchen staff, or wilderness leaders before moving into senior roles.

Staff members Dan Harris, Di Gradstein, and Mimi Gordon enjoying a day off

Staff members Dan Harris, Di Gradstein, and Mimi Gordon enjoying a day off

Year-round staff team photographed near the San Francisco office in the early 2000s. From left: Sarah Rubinett, Gregg Rubenstein, Kamala (Butler) Brown, Zack Rawlins, Nina Kaufman, Noah Dort, Mimi Gordon, Lom Friedman, Sarah Lefton. Not pictured: Ken Kramarz, Deborah Newbrun, Ann Gonski.

Year-round staff team photographed near the San Francisco office in the early 2000s. From left: Sarah Rubinett, Gregg Rubenstein, Kamala (Butler) Brown, Zack Rawlins, Nina Kaufman, Noah Dort, Mimi Gordon, Lom Friedman, Sarah Lefton. Not pictured: Ken Kramarz, Deborah Newbrun, Ann Gonski.

Camp’s leadership transition was not a sudden passing of the torch. It was a gradual process, carried by people who already knew the place deeply and had been helping lead it for years.

Current camp director (then director of Teen Service Learning) Aaron Mandel, 2008

Current camp director (then director of Teen Service Learning) Aaron Mandel, 2008

Kylie Simon (left) with Jamie Simon, camp director, holding the Torah scroll, 2008

Kylie Simon (left) with Jamie Simon, camp director, holding the Torah scroll, 2008

Ryley (Share) Katz and Mimi Gordon, 2002

Ryley (Share) Katz and Mimi Gordon

This 2004 staff photo brings the decade’s generational story into view: longtime leaders, senior staff, and future directors all gathered in one frame.

The senior directors are in the front row.

Ken Kramarz, executive director in 2004.

Deborah Newbrun, camp director in 2004.

Mimi Gordon, associate camp director in 2004. Gordon is currently Camp Tawonga's interim chief program officer.

Gregg Rubenstein, business manager in 2004.

Nina Kaufman, director of Teen Service Leadership in 2004. (Kaufman was a previously a longtime kitchen manager and continues to return to Tawonga at the beginning of every summer to help train kitchen staff.)

Lom Friedman, director of wilderness programs in 2004. Friedman has remained involved with Tawonga for decades. He began working as a lead educator for the B*Mitzvah program in 2022.

Now let's look at some other familiar faces in the crowd.

Josh "Frisco" Goldstein, counselor in 2004. He joined the year-round team in 2019. Goldstein is currently the director of kitchen and at-camp operations.

Aaron Mandel, counselor in 2004. Mandel joined the year-round staff in 2007, serving in multiple roles. He has served as camp director since 2023.

Ashley (Warner) Costello, assistant unit head in 2004. Costello joined the year-round staff in 2009 and has served multiple roles. She is currently Tawonga's senior director, camper care.

Kiyomi Gelber, counselor in 2004. Gelber joined Tawonga's year-round team in 2018 and currently serves as senior director of equity, justice, and inclusion.

Ben Simrin, counselor in 2004. Simrin joined the full-time staff in 2015. He is currently Tawonga's registrar and financial assistance manager.

Jamie Simon, unit head in 2004. Simon served as camp director from 2007 to 2016 and chief executive officer from 2017 to 2023. She is currently CEO of the Foundation for Jewish Camp.

Myla Marks, wilderness leader in 2004. Marks was on the year-round staff from 2016 to 2024, first as director of wilderness programs and then as senior director.

Brady Gill, drama specialist in 2004. Gill was on the year-round staff from 2023 to 2026 after filling multiple director and supervisory roles on summer staff over the years.

Becca Meyer, unit head in 2004. Meyer served as camp director from 2017 to 2022 and chief executive officer from 2024 to2026. She is currently chief impact officer of the Foundation for Jewish Camp.

The continuity was already visible: several generations leading Tawonga together.

Changes in the executive director role began after the summer of 2005, when Ken Kramarz stepped down after two decades in the position. (He would later return to the role in 2011.)

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, September 16, 2005

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, September 16, 2005

Deborah Newbrun, who had been leading camp alongside Kramarz since the 1980s, became executive director in 2006.

Deborah Newbrun, left, with Jonathan Ferris on guitar, mid-2000s

Deborah Newbrun, left, with Jonathan Ferris on guitar, mid-2000s

When Newbrun left the following year for a new role at the San Francisco JCC, longtime administrative director Ann Gonski served as interim executive director while the board conducted a search.

Ann Gonski in the Camp Tawonga garden

Ann Gonski in the Camp Tawonga garden

Throughout these changes, Tawonga continued to benefit from experienced year-round leadership, including Mimi Gordon’s steady presence through the decade (first as associate director and later as director) and the growing leadership of Jamie Simon (who became camp director in 2007) and Ryley Katz (who became assistant director of administration in 2006). The continuity of leadership, values, and culture during this period proved invaluable.

In 2008, Tawonga’s board of directors named Adam Weisberg as executive director. Weisberg, who had been both a camper and staff member in the 1980s, returned to Tawonga after nearly a decade as director of Berkeley Hillel and joined a leadership team that included Mimi Gordon (director), Jamie Simon (camp director), Gregg Rubenstein (chief financial officer), Ryley Katz (assistant director of administration), Becca Meyer (assistant director of wilderness) and Aaron Mandel (teen program coordinator).

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, September 21, 2007

The Northern California Jewish Bulletin, September 21, 2007

Adam Weisberg, at the stage with a camper, 2008

Adam Weisberg, at the stage with a camper, 2008

Adam Weisberg (right), with Ron Fortgang. Both were staff members in the 1980s.

Adam Weisberg (right), with Ron Fortgang. Both were staff members in the 1980s.

Casey Cohen, Isaac Zones, Ashley (Warner) Costello, and Dan Harris together in the Dining Hall in 2008

Ryley (Share) Katz and Mimi Gordon

Kiyomi Gelber and Ben Simrin, 2008

Kiyomi Gelber and Ben Simrin, 2008

Jamie Simon and Ryley (Share) Katz, 2008

Jamie Simon and Ryley (Share) Katz, 2008

Becca Meyer, 2008

Becca Meyer, 2008

Campfire Conversations

In 2002, Deborah Newbrun and Mimi Gordon began a new camp tradition: separate campfires for girls and women, and for boys and men. The gatherings gave older campers and staff space to talk openly about gender, relationships, expectations, and the pressures they experienced in their daily lives.

First all-women’s campfire, 2002

First all-women’s campfire, 2002

At the women’s campfires, participants explored subjects including body image, pressures to conform, inclusion, and ways women could support one another.

The men’s campfires invited reflection on masculinity, vulnerability, friendship, responsibility, and how boys and men treated others.

The particular conversations differed, but both created structured spaces for honesty, reflection, and mutual support.

These conversations continued to evolve as Tawonga became more attentive to gender diversity and inclusion. In 2017, camp added a Beyond the Binary campfire for campers who did not identify as male or female.

Gender campfires remain a staple of Tawonga sessions, expanding with the community while preserving their central purpose. The campfires of the 2000s marked an important step in helping campers talk directly about identity, relationships, and responsibility — and helped lay the groundwork for a deeper culture of consent in staff training and community norms.

Ashleigh (Ordin) Rubinsky, 2008

Ashleigh (Ordin) Rubinsky, 2008

Songleaders Marsha Attie and Gal Friedman, 2008.

During the 2000s, as new programs took root and leadership roles changed, Tawonga’s values and culture passed from one generation to the next — through teaching, mentorship, and the daily work of camp.

Ashleigh (Ordin) Rubinsky, 2008

Ashleigh (Ordin) Rubinsky, 2008